Dahiana Peterson :: Is the costs of education too high?

PBS NewsHour Logo

  • Episodes
  • Podcasts
  • Subscribe
  • The Latest
  • Politics

    • Shields and Brooks
    • Politics Monday
    • Supreme Court

  • Arts

    • Poetry
    • Now Read This

  • Nation

    On Sept. 4, NASA-NOAAs Suomi NPP satellite captured this view of Hurricane Irma as a Category 4 hurricane approaching the Leeward Islands. Photo by NOAA/NASA Goddard MODIS Rapid Response Team

    • Supreme Court
    • Race Matters
    • Essays
    • Brief But Spectacular

  • World

    People who fled fighting in South Sudan are seen walking at sunset on arrival at Bidi Bidi refugees resettlement camp near the border with South Sudan, in Yumbe district, northern Uganda December 7, 2016. REUTERS/James Akena - RTX2V727

    • Agents for Change

  • Economy

    • Making Sen$e
    • Paul Solman

  • Science

    Human brain, computer illustration. Photo by Sebastian Kaulitzki/via Getty Images

    • The Leading Edge
    • ScienceScope
    • Basic Research
    • Innovation and Invention

  • Health

    PHILADELPHIA, PA - JULY 20: Art Gutierrez, 42, holds an orange container, "trash can," filled with heroin powder, that he bought on Thursday, July 20, 2017, in Philadelphia, PA. Gutierrez who grew up in California, has been using heroin for two year and during that these two years he has contracted HIV and Hep C. (Photo by Salwan Georges/The Washington Post via Getty Images)

    • Long-Term Care

  • Education

    Angel Nalubega, senior at Antioch College, and Jeanne Kay, alumni relations coordinator, organize registration cards for at the Antioch College reunion weekend in Yellow Springs, Ohio Saturday, July 15, 2017. Eric Bates, an Antioch alumnus and the editor of New Republic, on the campus for a reunion with his fellow alumni. Bates calls Antioch a canary in the coal mine for much of the rest of higher education. Photo: Meg Vogel for The Hechinger Report

    • Teachers’ Lounge
    • Student Reporting Labs

  • For Teachers
  • About

    • Feedback
    • Funders
    • Support
    • Jobs

Newsletter Icon

Educate your inbox. Subscribe to ‘Here’s the Deal,’ our politics newsletter

Political analysis that you won’t find anywhere else.

What do you think? Leave a respectful comment.


Day 3 of Brett Kavanaugh Supreme Court confirmation hearings

PBS NewsHour Logo: Home

Matt Krupnick, The Hechinger Report

By —

Matt Krupnick, The Hechinger Report

Matt Krupnick, The Hechinger Report

  • https://www.pbs.org/newshour/education/low-income-students-struggle-pay-college-even-state-still-provides-help
  • Email

  • Facebook

  • Twitter

  • LinkedIn

  • Pinterest

  • Tumblr

Share on Facebook

Share on Twitter

Low-income students struggle to pay for college, even in a state that still provides help


BERKELEY, Calif. — An incoming sophomore at the University of California Riverside, Samantha Yazzie frets about the $20,000 she had to borrow — not for tuition, but for housing during her freshman year alone.

“I worry about paying it back,” Yazzie said.

In the seven years since prices started rising dramatically at California’s public universities, this state has swum against the tide by trying to ensure — more than most others — that its poorest residents can still afford to go to college.

It provides a comparatively large amount of financial aid, while its University of California system campuses offer discounts to lower-income students using, in part, money that comes in from their higher-paying out-of-state and international classmates.

graduation-gap But California’s attempts to keep college affordable mask the reality that the poorest students still struggle more than ever to cover its costs. Even here, rising prices have led three-quarters of the lowest-income UC students to take out loans , often for costs other than tuition — a significantly higher proportion than other income groups. A UC education now eats up nearly two-thirds of the discretionary income of families making $30,000 per year or less, according to the Institute for College Access and Success.

“Clearly something is going awry,” said Debbie Cochrane, the institute’s research director.

Related: New policies close off opportunities to college applicants in need of extra help

The net price of college — after financial aid and discounts are subtracted — is rising much faster for lower-income students than for their higher-income counterparts, an analysis by the Hechinger Report and Dallas Morning News revealed.

One reason for the inequity is the increase in merit-based rather than need-based scholarships, a system that disproportionately benefits higher-income students with college-educated parents as states and colleges try to keep those students from going elsewhere. Studies have shown many of those affluent students who receive merit aid are not actually high achievers .

The kind of income redistribution practiced by California, where higher-income students essentially subsidize lower-income students by paying full price, has been outright banned in some other states, said Sandy Baum, a professor of higher education administration at George Washington University and an expert on college affordability.

States including Arizona, Georgia and South Carolina, Baum said, now base most financial aid on test scores and grades rather than income, favoring students from well-funded suburban high schools, while New Hampshire and Iowa offer little or no aid at all for public university students.

Related: States moving college scholarship money away from the poor, to the wealthy and middle class

“They’re not doing anything to help low-income students,” Baum said. “I would say California is on the list of better states.”

Yet even though most financial aid there continues to be based on need, low-income students in California are still having trouble keeping up with tuition and fees that, at the 10-campus University of California system, have nearly doubled in less than 10 years, to $13,300. Total costs now average $34,500 a year before financial aid, and that includes living expenses that are higher than in most other states.

The tuition increases have not affected UC enrollment; the system continues to see a record number of applications.

The flagship, research-oriented, 240,000-student UC system is at the top of the California higher-education hierarchy. Then there’s the teaching-centric California State University and its 23 campuses, where prices for the 460,000 students are significantly lower than at UC. The state’s 113 community colleges serve more than two million students for an even lower price, and fees are waived for low-income students.

Related: Nonprofits step in to help students that colleges allow to ‘slip through the cracks’

Anecdotal evidence suggests the higher prices are persuading at least some high-performing students to forgo the UC system in favor of those other, cheaper options, which also have fewer resources to devote to them; the California State system spends less than half as much per student, and the community colleges less than a quarter, than the UC campuses do, according to the state Legislative Analyst’s Office .

Katherine Heater, a second-generation UC Berkeley alumna, has a 16-year-old son now considering his options.

“He’s thinking, ‘Maybe I’ll get a job and work for a while. Maybe I’ll go to junior college,’” said Heater, an adjunct harpsichord instructor at UC Berkeley. “That’s really different from when I was growing up.”

This year, in a deal between Governor Jerry Brown and UC President Janet Napolitano, the former Arizona governor and U.S. homeland security director, the university system agreed to freeze tuition for two years in return for more state money.

But most agree it’s only a matter of time before prices rise again.

Related: Colleges give drifting students maps to help them find their way to graduation

The annual “political lottery” — the university bargaining with state officials over money and funding — can’t be sustained, said John Wilton, Berkeley’s vice chancellor for administration and finance.

Stopping the universities from raising tuition may be attractive to politicians and students, Wilton said, but it also may have a side effect: lowering the quality of education.

“We have a real problem,” he said. “If you can’t raise tuition at Berkeley, you drive the best public university in the world into the ground. You need to evolve with the reality of the situation.”

This story was produced by The Hechinger Report , a nonprofit, independent news organization focused on inequality and innovation in education. Read more about higher education .

PBS NewsHour coverage of higher education is supported by the Lumina Foundation and American Graduate: Let’s Make it Happen , a public media initiative made possible by the Corporation for Public Broadcasting .

Jenna Tokeshi, a senior, studies at the UCLA campus on May 14, 2015. Tuition and fees at the 10-campus University of California system have nearly doubled in less than 10 years. Photo by Al Seib/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Go Deeper

  • higher education
  • rethinking college
  • the graduation gap

Matt Krupnick, The Hechinger Report

By —

Matt Krupnick, The Hechinger Report

Matt Krupnick, The Hechinger Report

Matt Krupnick is a freelance reporter and editor who contributes regularly to The New York Times and the Hechinger Report. He was a reporter with the Center for Public Integrity’s State Integrity Investigation and is a member of Investigative Reporters and Editors and the Education Writers Association. He reported from Mexico while living in Oaxaca. Matt now lives in Brooklyn, N.Y., with his wife, cat and dog.


Support Provided By:
Learn more

Educate your inbox. Subscribe to ‘Here’s the Deal,’ our politics newsletter

Full Episode

Wednesday, Sep 5

Additional Support Provided By:

  • Babbel

  • BNSF Railway

  • Consumer Cellular

  • Corporation for Public Broadcasting

  • Mutual of America: Your Retirement Company

  • Raymond James

  • Viewers Like You

  • Friends of the NewsHour

Trending Now

  1. Watch
    Sep 05
    Trump’s own officials see him as ‘detrimental,’ explosive but anonymous essay claims

  2. Read
    Sep 05
    5 takeaways from Kavanaugh’s first day of questioning

  3. Watch
    Sep 05
    What Kavanaugh said about abortion, guns and presidential pardons

  4. Watch
    Sep 05
    Florida’s toxic red tide is a perfect storm for the Gulf Coast

  5. Read
    Sep 05
    WATCH: A fast-talking auctioneer-turned-Congressman drowned out this far-right protester

The Latest

WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 05: Supreme Court Nominee Brett Kavanaugh departs following the second day of his Supreme Court confirmation hearing on Capitol Hill September 5, 2018 in Washington, DC. Kavanaugh was nominated by President Donald Trump to fill the vacancy on the court left by retiring Associate Justice Anthony Kennedy. (Photo by Zach Gibson/Getty Images)

Sep 05

5 takeaways from Kavanaugh’s first day of questioning

By Daniel Bush

WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 05: Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ) speaks during the second day of Supreme Court Nominee Brett Kavanaughs confirmation hearing on Capitol Hill September 5, 2018 in Washington, DC. Kavanaugh was nominated by President Donald Trump to fill the vacancy on the court left by retiring Associate Justice Anthony Kennedy. (Photo by Zach Gibson/Getty Images)

Sep 05

WATCH: Booker says effort to question Kavanaugh on race hampered by GOP

By Associated Press

The Twitter Inc. account of U.S. President Donald Trump, @realDoanldTrump, is seen on an Apple Inc. iPhone arranged for a photograph in Washington, D.C., U.S., on Friday, Jan. 27, 2017. Mexican President Enrique Pena Nieto canceled a visit to the White House planned for next week after Trump on Thursday reinforced his demand, via Twitter, that Mexico pay for a barrier along the U.S. southern border to stem illegal immigration. Photographer: Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg via Getty Images

Sep 05

WATCH: Kavanaugh won’t comment on Trump’s tweets about Sessions

By Associated Press

U.S. Supreme Court nominee judge Brett Kavanaugh testifies during his Senate Judiciary Committee confirmation hearing on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., September 5, 2018. REUTERS/Chris Wattie - RC1D7ABEB9A0

Sep 05

WATCH: Kavanaugh says he knew nothing about sexual misconduct allegations against judge who was friend, mentor

By Associated Press

Sep 05

WATCH LIVE: Day 3 of Brett Kavanaugh Supreme Court confirmation hearings

By News Desk

President Donald Trump holds a meeting with Republican House and Senate leadership in the Roosevelt Room at the White House in Washington, D.C., U.S. Sept. 5, 2018. REUTERS/Leah Millis

Sep 05

‘If it happens, it happens,’ Trump says of possible government shutdown

By Ken Thomas, Associated Press

Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey testifies before a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing on foreign influence operations on social media platforms on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., September 5, 2018. Photo by Joshua Roberts/Reuters

Sep 05

Twitter CEO says ‘shadow ban’ not impartial

By Associated Press

Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh testifies during the second day of his confirmation hearing before the Senate Judiciary Committee on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., September 5, 2018. REUTERS/Joshua Roberts

Sep 05

Kavanaugh declines to answer questions about extent of president’s pardon power

By Associated Press

President Donald Trump meets with Kenyas President Uhuru Kenyatta in the Cabinet Room at the White House in Washington, D.C. Photo by Leah Millis/Reuters

Sep 05

Bombshell anonymous NYT op-ed claims Trump staffers ‘resisting’ the president

By Zeke Miller, Associated Press

Sep 05

What’s happened since California let fewer families reject vaccines

By Laura Santhanam

Former first lady Michelle Obama speaks during the second day of the first Obama Foundation Summit in Chicago, Illinois, in November 2017. Photo by Kamil Krzaczynski/Reuters

Sep 05

Michelle Obama to headline voter registration rallies in Las Vegas and Miami

By Darlene Superville, Associated Press

Sep 05

WATCH: A fast-talking auctioneer-turned-Congressman drowned out this far-right protester

By Associated Press

Dr. Larry Nassar, a former team USA Gymnastics doctor who pleaded guilty in November 2017 to sexual assault charges, is escorted by a court officer during his sentencing hearing in Lansing, Michigan, U.S., January 16, 2018. Photo by Brendan McDermid/Reuters

Sep 05

Inspector general reviewing FBI’s handling of Nassar sexual abuse allegations

By Michael Balsamo, Associated Press

Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey testifies before the House Energy and Commerce Committee hearing on Twitter’s algorithms and content monitoring on Capitol Hill in Washington, U.S., September 5, 2018. REUTERS/Chris Wattie - RC129EA7CFF0

Sep 05

It’s not fair that victims of abuse and harassment ‘have to do the work to report it,’ Twitter’s Dorsey says

By Associated Press

Social Security benefits are likely to be a key talking point leading up to the 2018 midterm elections.

Making Sen$e
Sep 05

The Social Security myths you should know before the midterms

By Philip Moeller

For 45 minutes on Wednesday, members of the public were cleared from the Senate Judiciary hearing for Brett Kavanaughs appointment to the Supreme Court. The seats were cleared after repeated outbursts from protesters had disrupted the hearing multiple times. Seating for the public on Wednesday was reduced by half, to 22, on Wednesday after outbursts delayed the hearings on the day before. Photo by Lisa Desjardins

Sep 05

Public seating at Kavanaugh hearing cut in half, then restored again

By Lisa Desjardins

File photo by Carlo Allegri/Reuters

Sep 05

Justice Department to discuss concerns that social media companies may be ‘stifling’ ideas on their platforms

By Associated Press

File photo of a member of the Afghan security forces in Kabul, Afghanistan. Photo by Mohammad Ismail/Reuters

Sep 05

Twin attacks in Afghan capital kill 20, wound 70

By Associated Press

Police officers on Sept. 5 stand outside the City Stay Hotel used by suspects Alexander Petrov and Ruslan Boshirov. Photo by Toby Melville/Reuters

Sep 05

UK charges 2 Russians in absentia in nerve agent attack

By Jill Lawless, Associated Press

Sep 05

Kavanaugh denies misleading senators in 2006 testimony

By Associated Press